Colt Single Action Army 2nd Gen SAA .44 Spl. 5 1/2″ Revolver, 1958 C&R
SOLD FOR: $3,725.00
LSB#: LSB251203TH022
Make: Colt
Model: Single Action Army, 2nd Generation
Serial Number: 23069SA (All matching)
Year of Manufacture: 1958 / C&R
Caliber: .44 Special
Action Type: Single Action Revolver with Side Loading Gate Cylinder
Markings: The top of the barrel is marked “COLT’S PT. F.A. MFG. Co. HARTFORD CT. U.S.A.”, the left is marked “COLT SINGLE ACTION ARMY .44 SPECIAL”. The left of the frame is marked “PAT. SEPT. 19, 1871 / JULY 2, 72 JAN. 19, 75” and with a rampant colt logo. The left of the trigger guard is marked “VP” in triangle at the front and “p” at the rear. The right of the trigger guard is marked “O”. The bottom of the frame and the left of each portion of the trigger guard are each marked “23069SA”. The rear face of the cylinder is marked with a rampant colt logo. The inside of each grip is marked in pencil with the partial matching serial number “069”. There is a matching serial number on the face of the cylinder “23069”. The loading gate is marked with assembly number “941”.
Barrel Length: 5 1/2″
Sights / Optics: The front sight is a quarter-round blade fixed to the front of the barrel. The edge of the front sight has been painted white. The rear sight is a square notch at the rear of a groove in the top strap.
Stock Configuration & Condition: The grips are two-piece checkered black hard rubber grips with a rampant Colt molded into the top. They are original to the gun per the partial serial number on the inside. There are minimal handling marks and only minor dulling of peaks. There are no chips or cracks. Overall, the grips are in Fine condition.
Type of Finish: Blue, Case Hardened
Finish Originality: Original
Bore Condition: The bore is bright and the rifling is sharp. There is no erosion or fouling in the bore. In this writer’s opinion the bore rates 10/10.
Overall Condition: This revolver retains about 98% of its blued and case hardened finish. There is slight thinning of finish at the leading edges and at the muzzle. There are slight carbon rings on the cylinder. The cylinder has a thin turn line. The screw heads are sharp. The markings are clear. Overall, this revolver is in Fine condition.
Mechanics: The action functions correctly. Lockup produces no perceptible play. The Hammer spring is tight and the trigger is crisp. The cylinder’s bushing is separate from the cylinder. We did not fire this revolver. As with all used firearms, a thorough cleaning may be necessary to meet your maintenance standards.
Box, Paperwork & Accessories: This revolver comes with a Colt Factory letter.
Our Assessment: The Colt Single Action Army Second Generation represents Colt’s celebrated revival of its most iconic revolver following a fifteen-year production hiatus. Reintroduced in 1956, the Second Generation SAAs were produced using much of the original Colt tooling and adhered closely to First Generation specifications, bringing the legendary Peacemaker back to market during a resurgence of interest fueled by Western films, television, and an expanding collector community. This 1958 example, chambered in the desirable .44 Special and featuring the popular 5 1/2″ barrel length, qualifies as C&R eligible and reflects the high standards of early Second Generation production.
This revolver retains approximately 98% of its original blued and case hardened finish, with only slight thinning at the muzzle and leading edges. The cylinder shows light carbon rings and a thin turn line, consistent with careful use. The bore is bright with sharp rifling and no erosion or fouling, rating 10/10 in this writer’s opinion. The original two-piece checkered black hard rubber grips with molded rampant Colt logos remain in Fine condition, showing minimal handling wear and no chips or cracks, and are confirmed matching by the partial serial number penciled inside. All matching serial numbers are present, including on the cylinder face, and the markings remain clear. The action functions correctly with tight lockup, no perceptible play, a strong hammer spring, and a crisp trigger pull.
Overall, this is a fine and highly desirable example of a 1958 Colt Single Action Army in .44 Special, combining strong originality, matching numbers, excellent bore condition, and Colt factory documentation. With its classic configuration and included Colt Factory letter, it would make a standout addition to any Colt collection or investment-grade accumulation. Please see our photos for a better understanding of condition and good luck with your bids!
BF